Spooky Monster Cookies

There’s three things about October that I love – fall foliage, apple picking and Halloween. I can certainly do without the cold weather and freezing temps that we are already receiving at night. I’m always looking forward to an excuse to bake so this past week I surprised the neighborhood kids all with a few spooky treats to kick off October and Halloween Season. Celebration by Frey™ and Sixlets® products provide a fun, easy, and affordable way to make this years Halloween party the most memorable one ever!

easy-halloween-cookies halloween-monster-cookie-recipe
If you’re trying to find a spooky treat to make for your next Halloween party or just want to surprise the kids with a treat after school, these Monster Cookies are super easy to make. Use your favorite chocolate chip cookie recipe except swap out the chocolate chips with Halloween colored Sixlets. Make a sandwich using 2 cookies and frosting then add the marshmallow and Googlie Eyes Gumballs to create a monster.

Spooky Monster Cookies


  • 2 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 1 cup butter, softened
  • 3/4 cup granulated sugar
  • 3/4 cup packed brown sugar
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 2 large eggs
  • 2 cups Sixlets
  • mini marshmallows
  • frosting
  • Googlie Eyes Gumballs


  • Preheat oven to 375° F.
  • Combine flour, baking soda and salt in a small bowl.
  • In a large mixer, beat butter, granulated sugar, brown sugar and vanilla extract until creamy. Add eggs, one at a time, beating well after each. Slowly add in flour mixture.
  • Drop rounded tablespoon onto ungreased baking sheets.
  • Bake 9 to 11 minutes or until golden brown. Remove from oven and carefully press Sixlets on top. Cool on baking sheets for a few minutes then remove to wire racks to cool completely.
  • Frost the top of one cookie, add a second cookie on top making a sandwich.
  • Add mini marshmallows to make teeth.
  • Add additional frosting on top and add two eyes.




You can find the Celebration by Frey and Sixlets at Hobby Lobby, Wegmans, Meijer, Walmart and many more!

Candy buffets, cookies, cakes, or cupcakes….Celebration by Frey candy and Sixlets bring fun to any Halloween and Fall events.

Do you have a favorite recipe to make for Halloween?




  1. edye says:

    I like the black and white candy crumble! Because it could be used for many different things.

  2. Dotty J Boucher says:

    I wouldn’t mind these Snowflake Mix Pearls Small Peg Pouch, I think they are pretty and thinking all the wonderful things I can do with them..

  3. heather kaufman says:

    I like the Halloween mix Sixlets shaker jar. My kids would have a great time decorating cookies with them.

  4. Sara Theissen says:

    I would love the Googlie Eyes Gumballs Peg Pouch (1.41oz)! You could make many cute concoctions with those!

  5. paige chandler says:

    I love the google eye gumballs. I would be mom of the year.

  6. DEBIJOT says:

    I would like to try the Halloween mix gumballs because I think the kids would love them.

  7. Jennifer H. says:

    I would like the Spooky Eyes Gumballs Peg Bag.

  8. elizabeth miller says:

    We would love the Halloween mix gumballs and the Nerd filled gumballs. My daughter would love to have these because the girl is constantly chewing gum. She would love the decorative colors and the nerds.

  9. John H. says:

    I think that the Witch’s Brew and the Spooky Eyes Gumballs are cool!

  10. Amanda Patterson says:

    I really like the Halloween Mix Sixlets Shaker Jar (4.5oz)! I think the colors are so fun and perfect for halloween and I think they would be good on cupcakes or candies!

  11. Sara says:

    I want to try eyeball gum

  12. Kimberly Flickinger says:

    I would use the Halloween Mix Sixlets Shaker Jar to decorate sugar cookies and cupcakes.

  13. Shannon says:

    I want to get a bag of black gumballs to make spiders to give out.

  14. Patricia Wojnar Crowley says:

    I’d love to get the googlie eyes. I’ve been wanting to make that cookie monster fudge from pinterest!

  15. barbg says:

    I would want to get it all because it all looks great. I absolutely love candies and the halloween sixlets.. I like their sixlets in red and all of the other rainbow colors. Love all of the decorative sprinkles too.

  16. rochelle haynes says:

    I like the spooky gumball eyes

  17. Paulette Dorland says:

    I love all the different ideas. I have 5 grandkids and am always looking for new things to do for them.

  18. June S. says:

    I would like some of these for our Halloween candy bowl on our dining room table; Foiled Solid Milk Orange Balls

  19. Darlene Owen says:

    I love the Lavender & White Candy Crumble Small Peg Bag as I love the color of purple.

  20. Julie Bickham says:

    Would like to get the Halloween Mix Sixlets. We can decorate Halloween cupcakes with these.

  21. Kristen Joiner says:

    I love the Black and Orange bags of gumballs the most. Not only would those make great eyes on a cake, but I like gum so it’s tasty too.

  22. Dawn Monroe says:

    I’d buy the black gumballs to use as eyes.

  23. Tiffany S says:

    I like the spooky gumball eyes because there is so much you can make with them.

  24. Soha Molina says:

    I like gumballs because they are fun.

  25. Sarah Hall says:

    I would like to have the Halloween Sixlets as they are so good.

  26. kelly nicholson says:

    sixlets are always my favorite,you can pretty much add them to anything,cup cakes,cakes,cookies,or just eat them out of the bag thanks

  27. Nancy says:

    I like their Orange Foil Wrapped Milk Chocolate Balls because they would be colorful in a candy dish.

  28. Ann Fantom says:

    I would like to get the Celebrations by Frey’s Spooky Eyes Gumballs because they would make great Halloween gifts for my nieces and nephews.

  29. Judy Cox says:

    I love their sixlet candies. They are so good and chocolaty.

  30. I’d like the Spooky Eye Gumballs so I can give people the evil eye.

  31. Nicole Carter (Weasley) says:

    I want Shimmer Orange Sixlets because Halloween is my favorite holiday and I know I can whip up some awesome creations with those!

  32. Lissa Crane says:

    I would love to have the 8ozPeg Bag of Spooky Eyes Gumballs! With four kiddo’s, ranging in ages, we are huge Halloween fans and these gumball eyes would be perfect for all the classroom parties for everything from cupcake decorations, to candy spiders! I love the cookies you did in this post and how they look in the box too! I think I’ll give your idea a try for a class party too!

  33. I like the Orange Sixlets Peg Bag. I like Sixlets

  34. laura g says:

    I would love the Shimmer Girl Camo Sixlets Peg Pouch (1.75oz) for our youngest daughter’s birthday! They would be perfect for her cupcakes.

  35. Amber Terry says:

    I would love to get the Halloween Mix Sixlets because I love the colors and the taste of Sixlets 🙂

    Thanks for the chance to win!

  36. Terra Heck says:

    I’d like to have the Red Gumballs Peg Bag (8oz). They’d work well with a Halloween treat I’m making, and I really like the dark red color. Thanks.

  37. Julie Lundstrom says:

    I like the Halloween Sixlets Shaker.

  38. Nannypanpan says:

    I like the foiled solid milk red balls. Cause they are all red which is my kids favorite and he loves chocolate balls

  39. Veronica L says:

    I would love to get their Reindeer (6oz) and their Foiled Solid Milk Red Hearts. With 4 boys in this house who all love candy and to cook & decorate, these would be a lot of fun to use in our recipes to decorate with.

  40. Jillian Too says:

    I’d love to get the Halloween Mix Sixlets Shaker Jar because I’m a fan of sixlets.

  41. Joan Kubes says:

    I’d like to get the Foiled Milk Peanut Butter Filled Hearts. I bet they’re yummy!

  42. My kids love the gumball eyeballs they have plans for scarry faces

  43. Marilyn Nawara says:

    I like the Googlie Eyes Gumballs — these are a little creepy and would be great for decorating cupcakes.

  44. Carolsue says:

    I’d love to have the Ovation Creme de Raspberry Break-Aparts

  45. Jennifer Rogers says:

    I would most like to get the Aura Almond Intrigue because I live almonds and milk Chocoalte and these look scrumptious!

  46. Heather Poindexter says:

    I love the Googly eye gumballs. They can be used so many different ways.

  47. Charlene S. says:

    The Black Pearls Shaker Jar would be great for using as eyes on my spider cupcakes.

  48. polly says:

    In a tall glass decanter I would layer the Halloween Mix Gumballs, Spooky Eyes Gumballs and Google Eyes Gumballs to use as a centerpiece on my dining room table for Halloween.

  49. bn100 says:

    Girl Camo Mix Pearls Candies Peg Pouch (1.75oz) looks fun

  50. Mary Rutter says:

    I would like the Halloween Mix Gumballs because I love gum

  51. Amy Franz says:

    I would love to try the eyeball gumballs, because my daughter would think they are hilarious

  52. Vickie says:

    Well I really love Frey Easter chocolate line.
    These Halloween gumball mix looks good and snowflakes for Christmas

  53. Jeanna Massman says:

    My grandson and I would enjoy using the Halloween mix sixlets shaker jar jar to decorate cookies.

  54. Kim Pinch says:

    I would like the Lime Green & White Candy Crumble Small Peg Bag to make some halloween cupcakes.

  55. Katie Bellamy says:

    I’ve got some cute ideas for the Halloween Mix Sixlets Shaker Jar!

  56. Rebecca b says:

    I love the googly eyes.

  57. Soha Molina says:

    I like Lavender & White Candy Crumble they look fun.

  58. Tina Bartunek says:

    I would love to try the Shimmer Orange Sixlets Stand Up Bag for my cupcakes.

  59. Candace Galan says:

    The Orange Shimmer Sixlets, would be perfect for Halloween cupcakes!

  60. LaTanya says:

    Googlie Eyes Gumballs Peg Pouch (1.41oz) because they would make for fun candy decor.

  61. Robin Abrams says:

    I like the Spooky Eyes Gumballs Peg Bag . I think the kids would love them

  62. betty league says:

    I would like the Halloween Mix Sixlets Peg Bag – 14oz – if I won – thanks

  63. Vikki Billings says:

    I would love to receive the Shimmer Spring Mix Sixlets Peg Bag because I LOVE sixlets and the colors are very cool on these!

  64. With all the morons trying to destroy Halloween for the little kids, we have decided to do a craft day with friends and family. The kids can all decorate their treats that we bake and the Halloween Mix Sixlets Shaker Jar would be perfect for that! Cute monster cookies – we may have to try them too 😉

  65. Elizabeth H. says:

    Would love the Sixlets Peg Bag.

  66. sarah says:

    the sixlets peg bag. its adorbs!

  67. Cait says:

    The spooky monster cookies are sooo cute!

  68. Heather says:

    I like the Gum Eyeballs. I’d give them to my unsuspecting kids.

  69. Shelley P says:

    I’d like to hand out the Foiled Solid Milk Jack-O-Lantern Discs this Halloween. I think the different faces are adorable and everyone loves chocolate 🙂

  70. Aaron says:

    I would most like to give and get the Googlie Eyes Gumballs Peg Pouch because they seem silly and fun!

  71. Angela Saver says:

    I would love to get the Spooky Eyes Gumballs Peg Bag so my daughter & I can decorate our Halloween cupcakes!

  72. Heather B says:

    The Eyeball Gumballs would look great in our gumball machine.